فیلم The Grey 2011

متن بررسی: من واقعاً متعجبم که چگونه این همه نفر در IMDb به این فیلم ۸، ۹ و حتی ۱۰ ستاره داده‌اند. شاید این فیلم بدترین فیلمی که دیده‌ام نباشد، اما به هیچ وجه ارزش چنین امتیازی را ندارد. نقطه قوت فیلم، لیام نیسون است که با بازی لذت‌بخش خود، تجربه خوبی را به وجود می‌آورد. او تقریباً تنها دلیلی است که من به این فیلم ۴...

متن بررسی: من واقعاً متعجبم که چگونه این همه نفر در IMDb به این فیلم ۸، ۹ و حتی ۱۰ ستاره داده‌اند. شاید این فیلم بدترین فیلمی که دیده‌ام نباشد، اما به هیچ وجه ارزش چنین امتیازی را ندارد. نقطه قوت فیلم، لیام نیسون است که با بازی لذت‌بخش خود، تجربه خوبی را به وجود می‌آورد. او تقریباً تنها دلیلی است که من به این فیلم ۴ ستاره IMDb داده‌ام. بقیه فیلم به طرز واضحی نادرست است. اولین تأثیر من این است که این کارگردان به فیلم‌برداری قدیمی علاقه‌مند است! حالا این یک مسئله سلیقه است، اما من از این که فیلم‌ها به طرز مصنوعی به نظر می‌رسند که انگار روی فیلم‌های قدیمی و بی‌کیفیت ضبط شده‌اند، خوشم نمی‌آید. این نوع فیلم‌برداری در برخی موارد جای خود را دارد، اما در اینجا چیزی به فیلم اضافه نکرده است. فیلم با سقوط یک هواپیما آغاز می‌شود که به خوبی انجام نشده است. نه از نظر جلوه‌های ویژه و نه از نظر واقع‌گرایی. متأسفانه، عدم واقع‌گرایی throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout throughout در این فیلم، ما شاهد داستانی هستیم که ریشه‌های عمیق انسانی و فلسفی دارد. در کل، این فیلم با وجود برخی نقاط ضعف، داستانی خاص و به یاد ماندنی را ارائه می‌دهد که ارزش تماشا دارد.